Download response-to-alan-hart-by-zahir-ebrahim2.pdf

Contents : Zahir Ebrahim's Response to Alan Hart's 'Palestinian people power could it be a game-changer ' Project Humanbeingsfirst.org Friday July 08 2011 Revised July 09 2011 First of all thanks to Alan Hart for his article which I read on Salem-News. It takes a brave man to see and even braver one to speak. Zionism is indeed the Jews' worst enemy. However when we focus on Zionism we somehow seem to overlook that it was constructed by someone. Who What for Who aids and abets it How has it lasted that long Which forces drive it so that it has endured for almost 200 years AIPAC Chabad The Knesset Washington My critique of Alan Hart and of most of the conscionable Western witnesses to the genocidal crimes against humanity being purveyed upon an indigenous peoples in Palestine during our own lifetime (not something we just read about in history books and for which we can do nothing about today) is that they only speak of what they see rather eloquently too but almost always superficially. Yes we all can see the dead bodies doesn't take a Nostradamus to perceive what's already before one's eyes. But they don't speak of what they don't see. Like the iceberg 90% is hidden from sight. And like the iceberg it is also known to exist and to lurk just beneath the surface. It is not secret or esoteric knowledge nor is it a classified statesecret. And just like it is for the iceberg most descriptions of it only describe the visible 10% above the surface. I am not sure what profound wisdom is gleaned from reading such narratives. I am sure studying and documenting crimes against humanity is necessary. If eruditely documenting is the main purpose than I believe people are doing a terrific job of it. Even the senior Bush White House advisor proclaimed this to the New York Times in 2004: We re an empire now and when we act we create our own reality. And while you re studying that reality judiciously as you will we ll act again creating other new realities which you can study too and that s how things will sort out. We re history s actors . . . and you all of you will be left to just study what we Zahir Ebrahim's Response to Alan Hart's 'Palestinian people power - could it be a game-changer ' 1/15 do. Senior Bush Advisor The New York Times October 17 2004 But if changing what the history's actors are doing before they accomplish all their goals in incremental stages is the main goal of dissent then these erudite documentations etc. are as meaningless as boasted above by the history's actors themselves. This is an empirical fact. Not a matter of opinion. If no thinker and lauded exponent of Palestine will see the 90% which gives the entire foundational substance to the visible 10% then their articulation of the problem is only as deep (or shallow) as the 10% visible iceberg. It is forever relegated to studying the new realities being daily created by the history's actors . As they like to put it with considerable chutzpah and hubris to just study what we do. So in my moments of stupidity (since no brilliant peoples like all the Nobel peace prize winners and academic professors and scholars ever seem to think of this I must be the stupid one to do so) I have to wonder that while how easy it is to see the 10% of the visible iceberg mass for dissent-chiefs why is it so hard to see the remaining 90% for those who do see the 10% Virtually without exception all famous and lauded narrators of Palestine in the dissent-space keep coming up with faulty frameworks to explain what they do see in Palestine. The rare exception which links it to the larger global agenda in the world is either immediately marginalized or ignored. Or the oddballs inexplicably marginalize themselves in the eyes of rational people who might otherwise pay attention to them by simultaneously uttering some outlandish gibberish. This blindsight amidst the learned simply drives me up the wall especially when peoples far more knowledgeable and experienced than I indulge in it. Why do they do that Are they blind Or are they stupid Or am I really really brilliant I would safely strike out the last item self-servingly put there if I were you because I don't believe it myself. Nothing I have said in the zillion words on my website is rocket science. Then is there some other reason for these stupidities which ought to remain unspeakable For what little my opinion is worth I have still tried to address this very question in my May 15 2010 Pamphlet: "How to Return to Palestine" ( humanbeingsfirst.blogspot.com/p/pamphlethow-to-return-to-palestine.html ). Zahir Ebrahim's Response to Alan Hart's 'Palestinian people power - could it be a game-changer ' 2/15 And in my view I am sorry to say that the heartfelt narratives of Alan Hart as truly heart warming as they always are seldom do any analytical justice to unraveling the core issues which pertain to the invis

INFO HASH : 4f21ce8599657c7573253c5bdb59d3fc52e2640b

Download now

File Size: 133.7 kb